Where is Environmental Regulation Heading in WA?

Another day in paradise

As a long standing practitioner on both sides of the fence (government and private)  in the area of Environmental Protection in WA, I am struggling to identify a clear direction or strategy with regards to the policy and statutory aspects of environmental regulation in WA.

There is a clear dichotomy between the two key regulatory agencies responsible for Environmental Protection in WA:

  • Under the joint and extended leadership of Paul Vogel and Kim Taylor the EPA has made great strides in terms of streamlining and clarifying the EPA Assessment process and articulating a clear policy direction.  The process now runs smoothly and there seems to be healthy mix of firm environmental protection and pragmatism that is producing outcomes that protect the areas of environment that matter while allowing development to proceed where it should.  It is sad to see Paul leaving this role before he has achieved everything of which he was capable (especially when rumour has it that he was keen to stay on).  Having said that, Dr Tom Hatton, his replacement is a very capable and experienced operator who I am sure can continue the good work.
  • The Department of Environmental Regulation on the other hand  has suffered through a series of reviews and restructures and has been lead by a series of Acting Director Generals, none of whom have had a good grounding in the field of environmental regulation and policy relating to environmental regulation.  The current incumbent, Jason Banks,  has a varied background including:
  • Being a detective in the WA Police Force
  • Being CEO and Co-ordinator of the Office of Energy; and
  • A range of senior management and review positions in the State Government.

This background may make him a competent  manager and able administrator but to date he seems unable or unwilling to articulate a vision and direction for environmental protection in WA.  Coupled with this, is the fact  that under his leadership the DER appears to be moving to an old fashioned command and control regulatory approach backed by an enforcement unit staffed, not by people with an environmental management background, but instead by staff sourced from a police enforcement background.   As a result there has been an increase in the number of prosecutions attempted but no evidence of a concomitant strategic benefit.

There also seems to be a lack of co-ordination and consultation between the various directorates in the agency with a series of policy documents released that fail to consider a whole of agency approach, let alone a whole of Government approach.  This is most evidenced in relation to the  series of Environmental Standards that are currently being released at the rate of 1-2 a month.  These documents and the whole area of waste will be the subject of subsequent posts.

We can only hope to see an approach  going forward driven by well structured and thought out policy that fits within a strategic framework and vision.


Hello world!

Noel Iphone 16 Nov 060

I have worked for 30 years in Western Australia in the areas of environmental protection and waste management and have now decided it is time to make greater contribution to the direction of  environmental policy in this State and Australia.

This blog will be an eclectic mix of comment on government policy and strategy, technical discussions and my thoughts on lifestyle and living in Western Australia.

I hope you enjoy reading it and participate by providing comment and feedback.  I only ask that comments are positive and constructive and concentrate on issues and do not include personal attacks or abuse directed at me or other commenters.  Such comments will be blocked or deleted.

When making a comment on an aspect of a post please make your point clearly by reproducing the relevant text or issue in your post and then adding your comment.

Regular Posts will commence shortly.  I apologise in advance for any formatting issues as I am still coming to grips with driving WordPress